The Pittsburgh Pirates’ journey over the past few seasons has been filled with rebuilding efforts, young talent development, and glimpses of potential. With free agency in full swing, fans are speculating about possible roster changes, and while signing former players is often a divisive move, there are several familiar faces who could help elevate this team. Here’s a look at four former Pirates who, controversially or not, might actually make sense for a comeback.
1. Gerrit Cole – The Ace the Pirates Desperately Need
Yes, it’s a long shot and would likely involve a massive budget allocation, but Gerrit Cole is arguably the most polarizing returnee fans could dream of. Cole, who left the Pirates to become one of the best pitchers in the game, has since dominated in Houston and New York. However, with Cole’s hefty contract with the Yankees, a hypothetical future return to Pittsburgh would mean major concessions from both sides.
For Pirates fans, bringing Cole back would be both exciting and controversial. Some may see it as a much-needed revival, while others may argue that this is exactly the kind of high-profile signing the Pirates have avoided for years. Nonetheless, his elite arm could provide the Pirates’ rotation with immediate credibility and much-needed consistency.
2. Starling Marte – A Familiar Face in the Outfield
Since his time with the Pirates, Starling Marte has shown his consistency across several MLB teams, most recently with the New York Mets. Known for his solid bat and impressive speed on the bases, Marte could bring back the defensive skills and offensive reliability that made him a fan favorite.
The downside? Marte is aging and has struggled with injuries, meaning that a return might not produce the impact some fans hope for. Additionally, some believe the Pirates’ focus should remain on developing young outfielders. Nonetheless, Marte’s veteran presence could be a valuable asset in mentoring the younger players, especially those who play in the outfield.
3. Andrew McCutchen – The Homecoming King
Andrew McCutchen’s name is synonymous with the Pirates’ most recent era of success, and he has an iconic status in Pittsburgh. Bringing McCutchen back could reignite a fanbase nostalgic for his prime years when he led the Pirates to the playoffs. While McCutchen is no longer the same MVP-caliber player he once was, he still provides a solid bat and a wealth of experience.
A McCutchen return could, however, stir controversy. Some fans may see his comeback as a sentimental move that distracts from the team’s more pressing needs for young, high-upside players. Yet, the emotional boost and ticket sales generated by McCutchen’s return could make it a worthwhile, albeit controversial, investment.
4. Tyler Glasnow – A High-Risk, High-Reward Reunion
Trading Tyler Glasnow to the Rays led to one of the most debated decisions in recent Pirates history. Glasnow went from an underwhelming Pittsburgh prospect to a top-tier starter in Tampa Bay. Injuries have been a recurring issue for him, but when healthy, Glasnow has demonstrated ace-level potential.
Reuniting with Glasnow would raise questions about whether the Pirates can handle a high-risk player with an injury history. Some fans and analysts might view it as an unnecessary gamble. However, with the Pirates’ need for a strong rotation, Glasnow could be worth the risk. The reunion would be a chance to make amends for a previous trade that many felt favored the Rays.
—
### Why This Could Be the Year for Big Moves
Bringing back any of these four players would undoubtedly be controversial, and for good reason. For years, the Pirates have maintained a reputation for letting go of high-profile players rather than pursuing them in free agency. But as Pittsburgh aims to regain its relevance in MLB, these types of signings might provide the experience, skill, and fan interest needed to finally change the team’s fortunes.
Whether or not these players return to Pittsburgh, it’s clear that the Pirates have to be willing to make bold moves if they hope to leave their rebuilding phase behind.
