In 2024, the WWE Universe finds itself buzzing with excitement, awaiting the return of The Man,Becky Lynch. Since her last appearance, Lynch’s absence has created a void in WWE’s women’s division, and fans are eager to see one of the most iconic female wrestlers in history step back into the squared circle. But how will WWE book her return? More importantly, can she regain the same momentum that made her a household name in the first place?
Here are four controversial ways Becky Lynch could make her return to WWE before the year ends—each with its own potential to shake up the wrestling world and redefine the women’s division.
1. Win the 2024 Royal Rumble in a Surprise Entry
One of the most buzzworthy ways Becky Lynch could return is by entering and winning the 2024 Royal Rumble. The Rumble is known for its surprise entries, and Lynch’s unexpected comeback would send shockwaves through the WWE Universe. WWE loves to build WrestleMania moments, and Lynch headlining the biggest stage of them all after a dramatic Royal Rumble victory would be a powerful statement.
However, this move could prove controversial. While Lynch is beloved by fans, some argue that WWE has relied too heavily on part-timers and returning stars for major Rumble wins in recent years. The women’s roster is full of rising talents—like Rhea Ripley, Raquel Rodriguez, and Iyo Sky—who could use a Royal Rumble victory to cement their own legacies. By giving Lynch the win, WWE risks alienating fans who want to see newer stars get their moment, leading to debates about whether WWE is holding back its fresh talent for the sake of nostalgia.
2. Form a Super-Stable with Seth Rollins
Another potential return angle for Becky Lynch is forming a stable alongside her real-life husband and WWE World Heavyweight Champion, Seth Rollins. The two have undeniable chemistry and WWE has teased their partnership before, but a fully-fledged power couple stable could dominate both the men’s and women’s divisions. This faction could include other rising stars, creating a modern-day “Power Trip” storyline, similar to Triple H and Stone Cold Steve Austin in the early 2000s.
The controversy here would be how much screen time the duo would hog in an already crowded main event scene. With Rollins consistently involved in title storylines and Lynch returning to reclaim her throne, other Superstars may find themselves pushed down the card. Fans who aren’t fond of mixing real-life couples with kayfabe storylines may also criticize WWE for pushing a personal relationship to the forefront of programming.
3. Turn Heel and Align with Damage
Perhaps the most shocking and unexpected way Becky Lynch could return is by turning heel and aligning with Damage CTRL, the heel faction currently led by Bayley. Lynch and Bayley have a storied history, both as allies and rivals. Joining Damage CTRL would offer Lynch the chance to showcase her versatility, playing the villainous role she hasn’t explored fully since her rise to stardom.
Fans adore Lynch as “The Man,and a heel turn could draw significant backlash. Her rise to fame was largely driven by her status as an anti-hero, a rebel who stood up to the system, and many fans identify with that persona. Turning her into a full-fledged villain might alienate parts of her fanbase. However, WWE has a history of pulling off successful heel turns when least expected, so this could inject new life into her character. The ultimate payoff of this heel turn would come if Lynch eventually betrays Bayley and asserts herself as the true leader of the group, leading to a high-stakes feud.
4. Return as a Free Agent to NXT
One of the boldest ideas for Becky Lynch’s return would be to have her show up on NXT as a free agent, similar to how Charlotte Flair did in 2020. Lynch’s presence in WWE’s developmental brand would provide a major ratings boost and give her the opportunity to work with up-and-coming talents like Roxanne Perez, Cora Jade, and Tiffany Stratton. This would allow Lynch to help elevate the next generation of WWE Superstars while staying relevant without crowding the main roster.
While this could help legitimize NXT as a third brand, it also raises questions about WWE’s reliance on established stars to boost NXT’s ratings. Some fans might see this as a demotion for Lynch, undermining her status as one of the top female performers in WWE history. On the flip side, Lynch could claim that her journey to reclaiming her throne begins by dominating NXT, building a compelling storyline that could eventually culminate in a main roster showdown at a future pay-per-view.
Conclusion: The Man’s Return, But at What Cost?
Becky Lynch’s return to WWE is inevitable, but the way it unfolds will be key to her long-term success. WWE has the chance to create a blockbuster moment by using Lynch strategically, but the promotion must be cautious not to undermine its full-time roster or rely too heavily on nostalgia.
Her return could reignite the women’s division, or it could trigger debates about WWE’s booking priorities. Whether she comes back as a surprise entrant in the Royal Rumble, forms a dominant faction with Seth Rollins, shocks fans by joining a villainous faction, or steps into the NXT ring, one thing is certain: Becky Lynch’s return will not go unnoticed. How WWE manages this high-stakes moment may define the landscape of women’s wrestling for years to come.