The 2024 MLB season was a tough pill to swallow for Toronto Blue Jays fans. A once-promising campaign derailed, ending with a 74-88 record and no playoff berth. The Blue Jays had high hopes after previous seasons of postseason appearances and a strong roster. However, inconsistent performance, injuries, and a lack of depth exposed glaring weaknesses, leading to another disappointing year. As the offseason approaches, the Blue Jays face tough decisions that could either restore their standing as contenders or push them further into mediocrity.
Here are 10 crucial changes the organization is expected to make as they look to recover from their 2024 woes, and the big question remains: Will these changes set the stage for a resurgence, or is another disappointing season looming in 2025?
1. Revamping the Starting Rotation
One of the biggest areas of concern for the Blue Jays in 2024 was the inconsistency in their starting pitching. Ace José Berríos had flashes of brilliance, but injuries and inconsistency plagued the rest of the rotation. A major change could see the Blue Jays targeting high-impact free agents or pulling the trigger on trades for proven starters to stabilize their pitching staff. Without improving their rotation, it will be difficult for Toronto to make a serious push next season.
2. The Future of Bo Bichette
Rumors have swirled around the possibility of trading Bo Bichette, their talented shortstop, to address other needs . Bichette remains one of the team’s best hitters, but his defensive lapses and inconsistency have raised questions about whether the Blue Jays might look to cash in on his value. A trade involving Bichette could bring in elite pitching or fill holes in the lineup, but losing him could also create a significant void offensively. How the front office handles Bichette’s future could define the next chapter for this franchise.
3. Adding Depth to the Outfield
The Blue Jays’ outfield production dropped in 2024 due to injuries and underperformance from key players. A critical offseason task will be adding both depth and quality to the outfield. While George Springer remains a core piece, his injury history raises concerns about long-term durability. Expect the Jays to prioritize finding a reliable outfielder, possibly through free agency, to complement their core.
4. Bolstering the Bullpen
The Blue Jays’ bullpen was another Achilles’ heel in 2024, particularly during key moments. While there were some bright spots, they lacked the shutdown arms needed for a contending team. Significant changes are expected here, with the team likely to pursue experienced relievers through free agency or trades. Bringing in reliable late-inning arms will be crucial if the Jays want to close out tight games in 2025.
5. Development of Young Talent
Toronto has a number of exciting young prospects waiting in the wings. Players like Damiano Palmegiani and other prospects who showed promise in the minors are expected to be part of the long-term plan . The Blue Jays will have to strike a balance between letting their prospects develop and bringing in veteran players to help the team win now. How they integrate this young talent could be a major factor in their future success.
6. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s Leadership
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. remains the face of the franchise, but after a down year in 2024, the pressure is mounting on him to deliver at an MVP level once again. Guerrero Jr. was recently nominated for the Hank Aaron Award, but his overall contributions were not enough to lift the team  . Toronto needs him to step into a leadership role both on and off the field in 2025, and a resurgent season from him will be critical to their success.
7. Managerial Adjustments
While manager John Schneider has the trust of the front office, there have been calls for changes in the team’s approach, particularly in high-leverage situations. The tactical decisions and how the coaching staff manages both the lineup and bullpen will need to improve in 2025. If the Jays don’t show progress early, managerial changes could be a real possibility.
8. Front Office Moves
Despite the disappointing season, GM Ross Atkins is expected to return in 2025 . However, the pressure is on for Atkins to deliver in the offseason. His job security could depend on the success of key offseason acquisitions and player development. Another misstep in free agency or the trade market could lead to calls for a front office shake-up if 2025 doesn’t show immediate improvement.
9. Shoring Up Infield Defense
Defense was a major issue for the Blue Jays in 2024, particularly in the infield. Costly errors and misplays led to extra runs, which the team struggled to overcome. Expect the Jays to focus on adding defensive depth and possibly shifting positions to improve overall defense. Whether through internal adjustments or external acquisitions, upgrading the defense will be a priority.
10. Player Conditioning and Health Focus
Injuries hampered the Blue Jays throughout 2024. Players like George Springer and Alek Manoah missed significant time, and it became clear that player conditioning and health management will need to be addressed in the offseason. Look for Toronto to make changes to their training staff or introduce new player health programs to keep their stars on the field.
Will These Changes Be Enough?
There’s no doubt the Toronto Blue Jays have the potential to bounce back from their disappointing 2024 season, but the path to success is not guaranteed. If the front office can make the right moves—particularly in upgrading their pitching and addressing their depth—they have the core talent to compete in the highly competitive AL East.
However, if these changes aren’t handled properly or if injuries and underperformance continue to plague the team, the Blue Jays could be facing another season of frustration. The offseason will be pivotal for determining whether the Blue Jays return to playoff contention or remain stuck in a cycle of underachievement.
For Blue Jays fans, the coming months will be filled with anticipation and hope. The moves made during this crucial offseason will not only shape the 2025 season but potentially the franchise’s future direction for years to come.
