As the Pittsburgh Pirates prepare for the 2025 season, General Manager Ben Cherington’s recent comments about their approach to rookie sensation Paul Skenes have ignited a heated debate among fans and analysts alike. Cherington’s strategy—aiming for flexibility rather than rigidity in managing Skenes’ innings—has raised questions about the long-term implications for both the player and the franchise.
Skenes, who dazzled in his rookie season with an 11-3 record and a staggering 1.96 ERA, is undeniably one of the most promising pitchers to come out of the MLB in recent years . Cherington praised Skenes’ performance but emphasized that the plan for 2025 involves a more adaptable approach to his pitching schedule. This decision has led to speculation: Is this flexibility a smart move to maximize Skenes’ potential, or does it open the door to potential injuries and burnout?
Critics argue that Cherington’s flexible approach could backfire. The inherent risks of pushing a young pitcher too far too soon are well-documented, and some believe that the Pirates should err on the side of caution. Instead of allowing Skenes to pitch freely, many suggest a strict innings limit could better protect his future. As one analyst noted, “We’ve seen too many young pitchers suffer from overuse; the Pirates should be learning from the past rather than repeating it”.
On the other hand, supporters of Cherington’s strategy argue that it shows confidence in Skenes and could be beneficial for both player and team. “Emphasizing a more modern, data-driven approach to player management can lead to innovative solutions,” said one prominent sports commentator. “In today’s game, flexibility might be exactly what a team like the Pirates needs to turn the corner”.
Cherington’s broader plan for the Pirates is also contentious. Following another disappointing season, his commitment to both internal player development and potential offseason acquisitions is under scrutiny. While he insists that the Pirates have a stronger core than in previous years, fans are left wondering if this will translate to meaningful changes on the field. After nine consecutive seasons without a playoff berth, the pressure is on Cherington to deliver results, and some fear that any missteps could deepen the franchise’s struggles.
Ultimately, as the Pirates head into a pivotal offseason, the question remains: Will Ben Cherington’s flexible plan for Paul Skenes prove to be a visionary strategy or a dangerous gamble? The 2025 season could be the turning point for the Pirates—one that might either elevate them back into contention or push them further into mediocrity.