The Green Bay Packers, a franchise synonymous with success and a rich football history, find themselves in a rare and unexpected rebuilding phase. After the departure of Aaron Rodgers, who had been the cornerstone of their offense for over a decade, the Packers are in the midst of a major transition. But despite what many pundits are saying, the path to the playoffs in 2024 is still alive—though it might not be the smoothest or the most conventional.
In this article, we’ll break down the controversial steps the Packers must take if they’re to make a legitimate playoff push this season. Forget the conventional wisdom and optimistic fan theories; here’s a reality check on what needs to happen.
1. The Jordan Love Project: Risking Too Much on a Single Player
Let’s start with the elephant in the room: Jordan Love. While some argue that Love is the future of the Packers, others believe that Green Bay’s success this season hinges far too much on a player who, despite flashes of brilliance, has not yet proven he can be a consistent NFL starter. To make the playoffs, Love needs to show more than just moments of promise—he needs to be the franchise quarterback that Green Bay believes he can be.
In 2024, Love’s growing pains are obvious. He’s had multiple turnovers in critical moments and has shown inconsistency in accuracy. But here’s the controversial part: the Packers can still make the playoffs if Love accelerates his development. The question is whether he will—and whether they can afford to keep throwing him out there as the centerpiece of the offense while dealing with inevitable growing pains. Green Bay needs to back him with solid coaching, protection, and playcalling to maximize his development. But that’s a risky proposition.
2. Rely on a Run-Heavy Offense, Whether You Like It or Not
In an era where high-flying aerial attacks dominate, the Packers may need to revert to an old-school strategy to stay relevant. The Green Bay offense should lean more heavily on their two talented running backs: Aaron Jones and A.J. Dillon. This could be a controversial move, especially when critics argue that the modern NFL demands elite quarterback play, but here’s why it might work:
– Time of Possession: A strong running game can chew up the clock, keeping the ball away from opposing offenses, especially high-powered ones like those in the NFC North.
– Pressure Off Love: With a strong running attack, Love won’t be forced to win games with his arm alone. This will give him breathing room to make mistakes and learn without the pressure of carrying the entire offense.
Sure, some critics will argue that it’s a step backward for a team that has been built around elite quarterback play. But given the current state of the Packers’ offense, a run-first approach could be their best shot at success this season.
3. Defense: The Underrated X-Factor
It’s not the first time we’ve heard about the Packers’ defense being “underrated.” But here’s the reality: if the Packers are to make a playoff push, the defense has to be elite—not just competent. The team is fortunate to have some standout players, including a promising secondary and a defensive line capable of pressuring quarterbacks. However, for Green Bay to truly have a shot at a wildcard or even a divisional spot, their defense needs to step up in a major way.
What’s controversial here? Green Bay’s defense has been inconsistent over the years, especially when it comes to stopping the run and closing out games in the second half. If they cannot consistently get off the field on third downs, the Packers will have a hard time competing in the tough NFC. The team must invest in their defense even more—possibly through more aggressive playcalling from defensive coordinator Joe Barry, including more blitz packages and innovative schemes that confuse opposing quarterbacks.
4. The NFC North: A Weak Division That Still Holds Promise
Some might argue that the NFC North is in transition, with teams like the Chicago Bears still figuring out their identity and the Minnesota Vikings possibly trending downward. This could be a golden opportunity for Green Bay to capitalize on a weaker-than-usual division and sneak into the playoffs. The Packers’ playoff hopes are directly tied to the NFC North’s unpredictability.
If Green Bay can continue to steal divisional games, especially against the Bears and the Vikings, they will position themselves well in the wild-card race. However, that’s easier said than done. The Packers’ historical dominance in the division won’t mean much if they can’t match up against a resurgent Detroit Lions team, which now looks like the NFC North’s biggest threat.
5. The Playoff Picture: NFC Wild Card May Be a Realistic Target
The most controversial opinion is that the Green Bay Packers’ playoff hopes this year should not be focused solely on winning the division but rather on competing for a wild card spot. The NFC is stacked with strong teams, but there is always room for one or two surprise teams to sneak in—particularly if teams like the New York Giants or Atlanta Falcons underperform. If the Packers finish with a respectable record, particularly through a strong second-half performance, they could find themselves in contention for that wild card slot.
The key to this playoff push will be maintaining consistency, especially in a tough stretch of games toward the end of the season. If Green Bay can avoid key injuries, get hot at the right time, and win close games—no matter how ugly—they might be able to pull off a shocking run to the postseason.
6. Coaching and Management Decisions: The Wild Card
Finally, the most controversial factor in the Packers’ playoff chances is the role that management and coaching will play. General Manager Brian Gutekunst and Head Coach Matt LaFleur have been under increasing scrutiny as they navigate this transition. In truth, their job security might depend on how this season plays out. If they can make bold decisions—perhaps even taking risks they normally wouldn’t—this team could pull off the impossible.
Whether that means trading for a veteran player midseason, adjusting the offensive system to better suit Love, or making aggressive calls on fourth down, Green Bay’s coaching staff needs to think outside the box if they want to remain relevant in the postseason race.
Conclusion: Unlikely but Not Impossible
Making the playoffs this season may seem like a stretch for the Green Bay Packers, but it’s not entirely out of the realm of possibility. The team needs to take calculated risks, manage their young quarterback’s development, exploit their run game, and rely on their defense to step up. All of these factors need to come together, and while it’s a long shot, this Packers team has the potential to surprise everyone—if they make the right, controversial moves.
