CBS Sports analyst Josh Pate has stirred the college football world with his recent comments questioning the legitimacy of the Texas Longhorns’ playoff aspirations. In a heated discussion, Pate declared, “I don’t think Texas should be in the playoffs,” sparking outrage from Longhorns fans and fueling debates among analysts and fans alike.
The Context Behind Pate’s Comments
Pate’s critique came amid discussions about the College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings, where Texas has been vying for a spot in the top four. Despite a strong 2024 campaign, including a statement win over Alabama earlier in the season, Texas has faced criticism for inconsistent performances against lesser opponents. Pate’s remarks seemed to focus on their narrow victories and questions about whether they would truly stand up against other elite teams in the nation.
“There’s more to playoff contention than just winning,” Pate argued. “You have to dominate, you have to look the part, and Texas hasn’t always done that this season.”
Fan Backlash
Unsurprisingly, Pate’s comments didn’t sit well with Texas fans, who took to social media to defend their team. Many pointed to the Longhorns’ overall record and strength of schedule, particularly their early-season triumph against Alabama.
One fan tweeted, “How can you knock Texas for winning close games when other playoff contenders have done the same? Pate is biased!” Another added, “The committee values wins, and Texas has delivered. Pate just wants drama.”
The Case for Texas
The Longhorns’ supporters argue that their resume is as strong as any other playoff hopeful. With a top-tier offense led by quarterback Quinn Ewers and a defense that has improved in clutch moments, Texas has proven they can win under pressure. Moreover, the Longhorns’ victory over Alabama remains one of the most impressive wins of the season, especially since the Crimson Tide are also in the playoff hunt.
Pate’s Bigger Argument: Eye Test vs. Results
Josh Pate’s critique seems rooted in the age-old debate over the “eye test” versus results. While Texas has the record and marquee win to back their case, Pate believes their overall performances lack the dominance expected from a top-four team.
“Look at Michigan, Georgia, or even Washington,” Pate continued. “These teams have consistently shown why they belong in the playoffs. Texas has been good, but good isn’t always enough.”
Does Pate Have a Point?
Critics of Texas point to close calls against teams like Houston and Kansas State, games that elite teams are expected to win convincingly. They also highlight that other playoff contenders have stronger finishes to their seasons, creating doubts about Texas’s ability to compete at the highest level.
The CFP Committee’s Dilemma
As the final CFP rankings approach, the committee faces a tough decision. Do they prioritize Texas’s record and signature win, or do they weigh the “style points” that analysts like Josh Pate emphasize?
The Verdict
Whether you agree with Pate or not, his comments have reignited discussions about what truly matters in college football’s playoff system. Is it the wins and losses, the strength of schedule, or the dominance displayed on the field?
One thing is certain: the debate over Texas’s playoff legitimacy is far from over. As the Longhorns prepare for their next challenge, they’ll have a chance to silence critics like Pate—or prove him right.
What do you think? Should Texas be in the playoffs, or is Josh Pate spot on? Let us know in the comments below!